x3 Spanges for Review

[Nydigger1]

Any input is greatly appreciated thank you (Although I suspect all 3 are bad, but posting here just in case).

Spange 1

[Nydigger1]

Spange 2

128703836_2718309445103087_7241221732670733255_n.jpg 128578719_1245616712462028_5590055927132204106_n.jpg 128578715_859984324757087_922921269639959589_n.jpg 128609616_222301719273570_629229406802833683_n.jpg 128595498_202691764697752_6076207905891762712_n.jpg

[Nydigger1]

Spange 3

128556865_379332613143802_4259486826780662028_n.jpg 128557272_1603588096480986_4811480175514527500_n.jpg 128565223_210809827096378_701260794338648466_n.jpg

[rbminis]

No, no, and no.
Ralph.

[callum]

Hi Nydigger1,
I do not think any of these are good.

The first appears to imitate an L/53, but the date and hardware are not correct.
The second seems to me a 'raptor fake' - one of the others may correct me on this.
The third I am not too sure about, the date, wreath and pin just seems off...
It is as if someone has heavily weathered these to try and hide the details.

Best regards,
Callum.

[Nydigger1]

Thank you both, into the repro box they go

[ben bijker]

The third is probably a post-war Souval clasp